Holly was returned to the show after a Final Jeopardy! clue that was deemed to be faulty. Another player in the same game, Brian Lamb, was also returned to the show shortly before Holly.
Her score made her unable to compete in Final Jeopardy! but she did receive the third place $1,000 prize. Tim Abou-Sayed ends her streak with a runaway and goes on to win two more games.